Page 1 of 1

New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Sat Mar 15, 2014 1:19 pm
by S. Heisley
Image

BIC has come out with a new product, an aluminum-enclosed disk filled with charcoal alternative fuel that fits very comfortably inside the table-top model of the Smokey Joe barbecue or other such cooker. You just take it out of the box and lay it on the bottom grid of your cooker and light it. When you are done and it has cooled, take it out and toss it. It looks like it might have some good applications for some of us. It is about 8" wide and about 1" tall. It costs about $4.50 for one; but, right now, there is a $2.00 coupon inside the box, good when you purchase two more. ...just thought I'd let you know, for your possible, occasional "clean" usage. (This wouldn't work for dutch oven users.)

PS. It's made in America!

Re: New Charcoal Product

PostPosted: Sun Mar 16, 2014 12:03 am
by Wolffarmer
Interesting, but I am to cheap.

:lol: :lol: Randy

Re: New Charcoal Product

PostPosted: Sun Mar 16, 2014 5:26 am
by rowerwet
fire and aluminum on my food, I won't do that. Aluminum gets into the food and then into your body, lots of research showing aluminum is the cause for brain related old age problems.

Re: New Charcoal Product

PostPosted: Sun Mar 16, 2014 8:12 am
by Woodbutcher
For a quick convenience once and awhile I could see doing this. But not as a regular thing. I usually bring a 5 gallon bucket with charcoal on my trips.

Re: New Charcoal Product

PostPosted: Sun Mar 16, 2014 10:21 pm
by S. Heisley
Oh, dear.... I have to admit that I was WRONG!

It’s not a new charcoal product. It’s a charcoal alternative. The disk is filled with ethanol made from corn. Ah, well.... I don’t think the aluminum is a problem because that is on the lower grid and the steaks were on a separate grilling surface above that; so, the steaks didn’t actually come in contact with the aluminum. I don’t know if the corn-based ethanol is a problem or not but I doubt it. If anybody knows for certain, please let me know. (Thanks.)

Tonight, I became the guinea pig as I tried that little disk out. I followed the instructions to a ‘T’ and barbecued some rib-eye steaks for 5 minutes on each side. Were they good? They had a lovely charcoal-like crust on the outside and were the perfect dark pink inside, for a steak done to Medium. The taste was good, too.

The flames are supposed to last about 40 minutes. I didn't intentionally time the disk; but, I started at about 5:30 and, when I looked at 6:18, the flames were out and the fuel was used up. I could see having one of these on hand for those times when charcoal is gone or running low or you're on a camp trip and don't want to waste time or cleaning effort. The only thing I had to clean was the food grill that the steaks sat on. This product seems pretty convenient.
Sorry, I can’t show you the results. It was yummy and went in my tummy...without delay! :Flippin Burger: (Besides, my camera is still broken.)

When I took the disk out of the package, there were instructions on the top covering of the disk. So, I pulled that off, washed and dried it and scanned it in, in case you want to see that part.

Image

Re: New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Sun Mar 16, 2014 10:45 pm
by working on it
It should be marketed as a two-pak with Jiffy Pop
jiffy_pop.jpg
jiffy_pop.jpg (37.15 KiB) Viewed 6640 times

Re: New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Sun Mar 16, 2014 10:57 pm
by S. Heisley
working on it wrote:It should be marketed as a two-pak with Jiffy Pop
jiffy_pop.jpg


HaHaHaHa! ...Good one~ :lol:

Re: New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Mon Mar 17, 2014 9:17 am
by rowerwet
working on it wrote:It should be marketed as a two-pak with Jiffy Pop
jiffy_pop.jpg

red neck fire alarm...

Re: New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Mon Mar 17, 2014 11:03 am
by the other side
I think that's spelled, redneck "far" alarm! LOL ;)

Re: New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 2:33 pm
by jstrubberg
Seems like a lot of packaging to me. Charcoal doesn't leave me anything to throw away, although it's definitely messier!

Glad it worked well.

Re: New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Fri Mar 21, 2014 9:47 pm
by S. Heisley
:lol: The box got recycled. Yes, I agree. I would think that they could market it without the box. The Jiffy Pop doesn't need no stinkin' box!

Re: New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Sat Nov 15, 2014 2:17 pm
by zekemedic
Glad you had a good experience with the Flame Disk - I wasn't so lucky :(
In my case it caught the BBQ's paint on fire! :shock:
my "little red" portable round BBQ had 36" high flames emanating from its burning paint - needless to say after I put out the fire with 2gal of water, I tossed out the steaks along with the now extinguished flame disk. Now my BBQ has to be repainted as it was burned right down to bare metal, & I had just bought the BBQ new this summer - Grrr!

Re: New Charcoal *Alternative* Product - Test Results

PostPosted: Sat Nov 15, 2014 7:40 pm
by S. Heisley
zekemedic wrote:Glad you had a good experience with the Flame Disk - I wasn't so lucky :(
In my case it caught the BBQ's paint on fire! :shock:
my "little red" portable round BBQ had 36" high flames emanating from its burning paint - needless to say after I put out the fire with 2gal of water, I tossed out the steaks along with the now extinguished flame disk. Now my BBQ has to be repainted as it was burned right down to bare metal, & I had just bought the BBQ new this summer - Grrr!


:shock: I'm sorry to hear that you had such a terrible episode with your Flame Disk! Assuming directions were followed, that shouldn't happen. I would send the complaint to BiC and see if they'll pay for a new BBQ. It sounds like that product may not be on the shelves for long!

:thinking: Then again, maybe you should send a complaint to the company that made your BBQ. The paint on a BBQ shouldn't catch fire so easily.