Check out these threads before you decide on an axle type.
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=32474 and
viewtopic.php?f=39&t=10923 Lots of info; really made me think about what I
needed for my recent axle replacement. I had considered going to a torsion, or a Timbren, but finally decided to stay with a spring axle, since I have always used them (stick with what you know). My TTT started out with a very small 1.25" square-tube axle of unknown capacity and manufacture. It was only 50"x60" on 8" wheels. I had intended to build under 1000lbs, so that wasn't a concern. As the build morphed into something much larger, and heavier, I grew concerned over the eventual failure of one or more axle components (probably the tube-spindle welds parting, being over twenty years old), or the thin-walled tubing (pock-marked with rust) giving way under excessive weight and road shocks. I had added bigger (new 5x4.5) hubs, 14" wheels and tires, and 1.5" spacer/adapters, which could only add to the stress on the system eventually. Just a matter of time. I took it out on one outing, just 100 miles round-trip, with no problems...but I worried about it coming apart anyway. So I researched and researched until I had finally decided on spring axle, again, just weight capacity to be determined. That was eventually decided on when I jacked the trailer up, in preparation to removing the questionable axle and installing a new one (at first thought a 2k from Tractor Supply). When lifted off the garage floor, the right rear spring shackle was found to have ripped loose from the frame (long story and thread:
viewtopic.php?f=21&t=58985 ), necessitating frame repair, as well as beefing up the entire structure...more added weight...so I decided to go big. New 1/4" thick frame rail repair pieces, heavy-duty spring hangers, and heavier-duty springs (3k capacity), on a Dexter 3500lb axle. Anticipating the new weight of the trailer to come in around 1750lbs, I ordered it with brakes.
Reasons for buying a spring axle: if a shackle or spring fails on the trip, I can use ratchet straps to limp to a parts house (I have done so before, with a broken spring on my tandem axle racecar hauler), I can carry extra parts with me (spring, u-bolt/tie-plate kit, extra hub/bearing, other hardware = total cost < $125, weight < 50lbs), and ease of assembly in case of repairs. The torsion axle requires a whole new assembly, and the Timbren would also, if repairs were needed on the trip. Since I plan no off-roading, and will monitor my new axle's condition religiously, at home between trips in the shelter of its' garage bay, I anticipate no problems in the future.