citylights wrote:Too much bouncy-bouncy on the springy thing on the Ghost Town Tour offroad trip. Did a field repair. Limped back to town. These springs were rated at 2000#, I think I will replace with 3000#. My trailer weighs 1750#.
Tough luck, but good recovery! And an eye-opener for me. Since my trailer is basically the same weight as yours, I worried about choosing the spring capacity when I was installing the replacement Dexter 3500lb axle. Others recommended 2000 lbs, I wanted at least 2500 lbs, and installed 3000 lb springs. I was influenced by this thread
http://www.tnttt.com/viewtopic.php?t=18700&p=252916"
Choosing your axle capacity?", which sold me on a 50% margin of capacity. I don't plan to off-road it, but given the deteriorating highways I travel, I'd rather be prepared for whatever comes along. I had previously investigated adding oversized bumpstops, but dismissed that idea, but I am now returning to it (and adding shocks as well). My trailer's first suspension failed,
http://www.tnttt.com/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=58985&hilit=fault so now I'm rectifying that, as penance! I'm no expert on trailers, or suspensions, but I've seen a lot of suspension breakage on various types of vehicles over the years, and should've known or at least have checked my trailer better before it broke (turned a blind eye to an incipient problem...never even checked bolt torque). A question: did you have bump stops or shocks? (I didn't see any in your build thread). When you went to larger wheels and tires, after increasing the ride height, you may have crossed a "line" regarding maximum allowable force the 2000 lb springs could absorb at 87.5% of rated load capacity. Increasing the size of your tires (= weight) increased the unsprung mass (see WIKI
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unsprung_mass) that the springs must control, while being acted upon by the washboard roads. The 1700 or so lbs of sprung mass, now at an increased distance from the ground, provided more room for unchecked flexing of the leaves. A bump stop, though giving a harder "felt" ride, would've limited the overflexing that possibly caused the breakage. Shocks would've also limited, and also smoothed out the forces. I am definitely going to add bumpstops and shocks before my next trip.