PMF vs Epoxy/Glass - TPCE Wants Your Vote

[KCStudly]

I keep trying to tell everyone that my work really isn't all that perfect. My poly has little jags and blips in it. I have no intention of going for a glossy finish on the outside.

The canvas actually seems to have a more uniform appearance than the glass, even after a fill coat of epoxy. If I had used a slurry of micro the glass might have come out ahead, but with just a single coat of thick Zinsser primer the weave of the canvas isn't really noticeable and there was a pretty even texture of little nibs that more or less sanded off. After reading thru West System's recommended procedures for surface prep and finishing again, there are more steps and materials needed to get a good finish.

I'm tilting back toward the canvas. Dessert Moose, ghcoe and several others have had the patience to do really nice work with canvas, and I think if I could do the same without issues of bubbling and excess shrinking, I could be happy with PMF.

So Rower, with all of your PMF experience (and I'm thinking you've worked with glass before, too), tell me a little more what you don't like about PMF and why you think I wouldn't like it.

Nice cozy wood inside, utilitarian outside, that was the original plan. The more I handle the sample the more I like it. (Tilting waffles.)

 

[Ned B-TNT]

hooray!

 

[rowerwet]

I use glass/epoxy at a minimum, on my ply boats I only do the seams with it. I'm a function over form person, so I do not feather edges out or try to hide the tapes.
My PMF is about the same, no pre sanding, no ironing, no washing. I use the cheap canvas. Cutting the seams out was my only nod to looks for the foamie.
I just figured you had gone a bit over the top for the tear, and my experience is that PMF would take more work to get a "factory" finish, YMMV.

 

[KCStudly]

Here I was thinking that the glass would be harder to get right.

I brought the two samples in with me to work today to see what my coworkers thought. Mind you that these guys are mostly blue collar tradesmen that work in industry and know a thing or three about what works and how things can fail. Also, they are hands on hobbyist in various genres, so I value their input as I would my TD brethren.

Dave the powder coater/machinist, who is all about show finishes and a car enthusiast was hands down in favor of the fiberglass citing durability and the ability to make a permanent repair that could be totally blended, whereas canvas repairs would be more like a patch (even though we know that you can fair the canvas edges with a spackle and glue mix, if you wanted to). Without prompting, he also concluded on his own that the FG would be more puncture resistant.

Don, the other machinist with a vintage Ford Mustang who tends to be more frugal and never makes hasty decisions, agreed with me that it would be a tough decision and abstained from voting.

Ed, the electrician who used to have a nice '67 Camaro and has seen TPCE in person, was hands down in favor of the FG saying that the PMG didn't seem to be up to the same quality standard that I have built into the rest of the camper (kind of the same as Rowerwet's thoughts).

Gardner, ex-Air Force QA liaison, liked the FG better.

See where this is going? (Tilt back toward FG, waffle)