IMHO mill finish is mill finish. Both will oxidize, both will stain, both will be tough to get stains out. I have used both and unless you want a used look real fast...go anodized. Of course it is more expensive , but you have the same look for alot longer (forever?) I have also polished both to a shine, but you will need a clear coat to keep that shine. If you choose either in mill finish, DO NOT use a standard nylon tarp to cover it...it will chemically react to the aluminum and cause large, dark, ugly stains that cannot be removed without heavy polishing, maybe not even then. I have a customer with mil finish that can verify this.
MRW...where are you located...Frank Bear has a wicked bright anodized that has the polished look and will retain it because it is anodized, but he is in Michigan
Here it is on top of my 70 Yukon...it has 3" creases that he offers also.
