KCStudly wrote:Some people have had problems getting the T-handle latch style to seal well enough. Either the gasket is compressed enough and the rods can still go in the holes, or not (skilled builders with well fitting parts seem to have less trouble with this; hatches with spring back, extra thick gaskets compensating for pour fit seem to struggle). I think the biggest attraction to them is the vintage appearance and one step operation in use (twist and lift as one action).
With the style of draw down latches you show, you can adjust the tension to pull the hatch into the gasket and there is no big issue with getting them to align and hook up before the gasket is compressed. That's why I chose the draw latches for my build. The draw back is that you need a separate handle to lift and it takes three actions (undo first latch, undo second latch, move to center handle and lift).
KC,
I agree with pretty much everything you said. There's really no adjustment with the t-handle latch, so either it's right or it's not. I suppose there could be movable blocks on the inside of the edge where it latches to provide some adjustment, but in any case it wouldn't provide the ease of adjustment that the RV-style draw latches provide.
But a separate handle isn't always needed with the draw latches, I don't have a separate handle on the cover for my military trailer, all it takes is a little tug upwards on one of the latches and then the gas struts go into action and the cover can be lifted with just one finger. The struts I've got installed on the TrailTop proof-of-concept work just about as easily, so I think it would be just fine without an extra handle.

One other area that the draw latches might be less convenient would be locking - they have a hasp for a padlock, which might be a little more trouble than a keyed t-handle, and the padlock(s) might rattle.
But the draw latches are far easier for the DIY-er to install and the adjustability is great.
There are plusses and minuses for both, I guess it's really a personal preference thing.
Tom - none of my garages have t-handles, so I'm not familiar enough with them to know how they'd work out in this application.