David Grason wrote:BTW, Kevin A, are you using Red Oak or White Oak?
I'm asking because I used to install both of these woods a lot when I worked as a hardwood flooring installer. I found that Red Oak looks harsh without some kind of stain to tone it down. White Oak, on the other hand, looks beautiful with no stain at all. I'd put on a coat of sealer and 2 coats of poly and it looked like a million.
But with Red Oak, when a customer explained that they didn't want any stain at all, what they usually were asking for was as light a color as possible. So I would first give the Red Oak a coat of Minwax Natural. Unlike other stains that have coloring agents, Minwax Natural has no color added. Instead it's based on linseed oil and gives Red Oak the perfect honey color and warmth that it needs. I never had an unhappy customer when I used it. Once you use it, you can then go with the sealer coat followed by 2 coats of poly or 2 coats of Tung oil or varnish. End it all with a good coating of paste wax, buffed out and you'll love it.
First I want to thank everyone for their suggestions
I wound up staining the red oak plywood with a cherry stain, it's still fairly light but it really brought out the grain in the wood. I'll be following it up with Minwax polyurethane. David, you mention a sealer coat between the stain & poly, what type of sealer do you recommend and is it necessary with the oil base stain? Here's a photo of how the walls turned out, there are a few more in my photo album. It's finally starting to look like a trailer again.
