by Changer » Mon Dec 14, 2009 8:35 pm
They still are, but the quality is (and realistically, according to shepherd folks I know, always has been) kind of spotty - I know two pet people who have gotten pet dogs they love frfom there and three who have not been UNHAPPY but felt the quality was not all it was made out to be. I don't think I'd call them a mill though- and realistically, there's a big gap between 'breeder I think is good enough to recommend' and puppy mill - and quite a few breeders that many people would find acceptable are ones that I still wouldn't advise training clients to look at and/or would actively warn them away from, especially in breeds like GSDs and BCs where there are so, so, so many people who are REALLY good at marketing their dogs and perhaps NOT so good at the breeding and genetics decisions.
Statistics of registrations show that the vast majority of registered dogs are bred by folks who breed only a litter every 5 years or less and that about 15% of AKC registered dogs compete in AKC events (conformation AND performance, including hunting events.) It's easy in working and sporting breeds to say "Look for someone who works AND shows, or at elast works" their dogs (and there are some people for whom the show-line working bred dogs ARE going to be a better match) but when it comes to companion breeds, the line gets fuzzier. Even if we assume ALL performance/show breeders are reputable (which is definitely not the case, Although I think more are than not), that still goes a long way to explaining the 'registered with papers!" dog that ends up in the shelter. Casual breeders- people who want 'just one litter' and give away the puppies without spay/neuter agreements to people who then repeat the process are, I suspect, the source of the vast majority of purebred dogs in shelters- not mills. (Which are a digusting problem, but numerically are not the main source of dogs dying in this country. They're just disgusting because dogs aren't livestock.)
Christie Keith says it best. Family pets from family homes.