by Redgloves » Thu Jan 26, 2012 8:15 am
Larry,
To answer your questions: I don't have a smart phone to get apps, can I just use a hand held GPS?
Which one is best??
Smart phone can be used, the GPS is not as accurate as a traditional hand held unit.
GPS units are of two main types: push buttons and electronic features similiar to smart phones.
First determine your budget. GPS unit prices vary from $100 to $600.
Nuvie's have been used, again have similiar issues like using smart phones.
Hand held GPS units are designed specifically for rugged use, while smart phones and Nuves do not have the same built in terrain safety features.
I can guarantee that the smart phone will be dropped on the trails, resulting in scratched and or broken phones. They are not meant to be wet, well should say, manufacutres know they will get wet, and have to be replaced. Added expense to you.
Hand held GPS units are designed for abuse. PLastic cases that should not break when dropped, are water proff upto 30 feet, contain seals to keep internal components dry. Screens should be more resistent to rocks and various mishaps.
My opinion: use Garmin only, most cachers use Garmin. Etrex units are good basic units to begin with. I have two Garmins. A GPS MAP 60 CSX and Oregon. Favorite is the 60 CSX. Depends upon if you prefer navigation buttons or electronic touch screen platforms.
Electronic platform units support the idea of paperless caching. Essentially and PDA and GPS is one unit. Very useful to have the cache page info while out in the woods. Some units do support added electronic caching options such as CHIRP and Where I Go's.
Able to download GPX files via pocket querries into unit with additional steps. Down loading the PQ's involves extra steps compared to the GPS Map units.
The antennas are internal, slower to respond, and decreased accuracy compared to the GPS Map units.
CSX units have an external, rugged antenna which does improve satellite reception compared to the Oregon. GPS Map units do not have the CHIRP and Where I go applications. Very easy to load GPX pocket querries either directly from geocaching.com or GSAK data base.
60 csx navigation buttons are fairly straight forward to understand the navigation process.
Most sales people do not understand the major pro's and con's of the hand held units and geocaching. Geocachers will be able to provide the most information on the various brands and models in relation to geocaching.
Word of advice: big box retailers will attempt to include warrenty programs, which appear to be a good idea.
From personal experience, the warrenties will not cover: broken screens from being dropped on rocks and water damage from prolonged submersion. GPS units will be dropped on rocks and streams. Been there done that. Broke one screen somehow.
Jean
Geocacher, healthcare provider, mom and women with not enough common sense regarding personal safety when it comes to adventure outings!
Owner:
Uff Da Inn, a 2015 Camp Inn 560