Teardrops n Tiny Travel Trailers

by **pepsifreek** » Sun Oct 19, 2008 7:14 pm

My wife and I are planning a cross country trip in December (Brrr) and want to do some dutch oven cooking. I have Lodge 12 QT DO that was great when the kids were still with us but now that it's just me and the wife I'm looking for something a bit smaller. I'm thinking about a 2.5 or a 4 QT (or maybe a 2.5 and a 4 QT :twisted:

) and a "double" pie iron.

I only have experience with lodge and wagner and would buy either but are there any brands that I should avoid?

Thanks!
Tracy

by **mikeschn** » Mon Oct 20, 2008 4:11 pm

I would check out the info on CI here

http://camp-cook.com/forum/viewforum.php?f=9

Mike...

by **jimqpublic** » Mon Oct 20, 2008 8:43 pm

The 10", 4 quart Lodge seems pretty good for smaller main dishes. The new 6" size is getting a lot of attention for side dishes and dessert- the Yahoo "dutchovencooking" group is having a recipe contest to generate interest.

by **Dean in Eureka, CA** » Mon Oct 20, 2008 10:41 pm

Can't think of any brands to stay away from...
Check for wall thickness consitancy... Thin areas can cause problems.
Make sure lid contacts top of oven wall evenly all the way around... Ill fitting lids are no fun.
If buying used items, like off of ebay... Be aware that some cast iron has been used for melting lead instead of cooking.

by **madjack** » Mon Oct 20, 2008 10:50 pm

...would say ditto to all Dean said ESPECIALLY the parts about thickness and lid fit...I also have a cheapie skillet, which I THINK came from Harbor Freight...it will not take a seasoning...no matter how long, how hot or what I have tried, it continues to ooze an oily residue, in a streak across the inside bottom...not very appetizing looking........
madjack

by **Joanne** » Mon Oct 20, 2008 11:02 pm

pepsifreek wrote:My wife and I are planning a cross country trip in December (Brrr) and want to do some dutch oven cooking. I have Lodge 12 QT DO that was great when the kids were still with us but now that it's just me and the wife I'm looking for something a bit smaller. I'm thinking about a 2.5 or a 4 QT (or maybe a 2.5 and a 4 QT ) and a "double" pie iron.

I only have experience with lodge and wagner and would buy either but are there any brands that I should avoid?

Thanks!
Tracy

Hi Tracy,

Any brand oven can put out a nice meal. From time to time all of the brands have a bad oven slip through quality control. I tend to buy Lodge ovens. Not because they are the "best" (whatever "best" means), but because they are still made in the US. That said, I do own Camp Chef and they are great ovens too.

As was previously mentioned, be sure to closely inspect whatever oven you decide to purchase. I've eaten some great meals that were done in Harbor Freight ovens. I sure wouldn't turn one down if someone offered to give me one.

Joanne

by **Mike B** » Tue Oct 21, 2008 9:37 am

Before you buy, check for cracks, thin walls and how the lid fits. If it rocks then it doesn't fit correctly. Try rotating the lid and trying again to see if it fits. If you get only a small bit of rocking, you can actually take that warping out by using valve grinding compound on the lid and the top of the DO.

I would stay away from big store brands. I went through Cabelas' ovens and every single one I looked at had a badly fitted lid. Even the 16" and 20" models.

Mike
Hayden Lake, ID

by **pepsifreek** » Tue Oct 21, 2008 6:54 pm

Thanks all, great link Mike! Bottom line up front, I'm sensing that buying cast Iron is a hands-on affair... There's a Dick's (sporting goods) close by that carrys camp chef and Texsport, I'll see what I can find.

More to follow

by **Franklin** » Mon Oct 27, 2008 9:32 am

I vote for Lodge as it does season the best so for me has been the easiest to clean up. Lodge does have special buys, recipes, etc. on their website: www.lodgemfg.com. I have gotten lazy as I age and if I have to scrub it, well, it becomes a planter in the yard. Also, I got a giant pot on clearance and it was so heavy..... :lol:

Cathy

by **starleen2** » Mon Oct 27, 2008 9:51 am

I bought a small set from Tractor supply Company and some from Harbor frieght - they work pretty good - they use a waxy coating that is hard to scrub off for the intial seasoning - I Just heat them to about 200 degrees in the oven and wipe of the residue with an old towel, then season as usual.

by **bobhenry** » Mon Oct 27, 2008 11:15 am

Ya don't have to fill the 12 qt full ya know ! :lol:

I have bought a 1/2 dozen new pieces and have about as many old
( ancient ) ones. It seems when I reach for one it's always the old ones. The years of wear only seems to serve to polish them smoother and smoother. They were made thicker and seem to heat much more evenly.
It may be all in my head ( other opinions welcome) but I would hunt antique stores , junk shops , flea markets and farm auctions for the GOOD ones. It's a great way to while away a weekend treasure hunting and you are sure to find other goodies you wern't even looking for.

just my 2 cents worth

Bob

by **pepsifreek** » Mon Oct 27, 2008 6:03 pm

bobhenry wrote:Ya don't have to fill the 12 qt full ya know !

Yeah, I know, but I'd end up frying my stew... Mmmm... fried stew... :thinking:

I have bought a 1/2 dozen new pieces and have about as many old
( ancient ) ones. It seems when I reach for one it's always the old ones. The years of wear only seems to serve to polish them smoother and smoother. They were made thicker and seem to heat much more evenly.
It may be all in my head ( other opinions welcome) but I would hunt antique stores , junk shops , flea markets and farm auctions for the GOOD ones. It's a great way to while away a weekend treasure hunting and you are sure to find other goodies you wern't even looking for.

just my 2 cents worth

Bob

I totally agree! There's nothin' like old stuff. (I think that's why my wife keeps me around

)

I've been to every nearby antique and thrift store and hit up the local sporting goods and kitchen stores and found a total of three DOs. All new Lodges and all bigger than I was looking for

The search will continue...

I did find these in the local thrift store

now all I need is some tiny groceries and a one ounce bag of charcoal!