by KCStudly » Wed Dec 11, 2013 12:19 am
Think of it this way, box tubing stiffens itself both ways in both directions (up and down, and side to side), as well as in a twist. This is because it is a closed shape and it has the fibers that do the work all out at the perimeter, increasing the relative moment of inertia (resistance to bending) for its weight.
Angle, on the other hand, is not a closed shape. Relative to the center of gravity of its cross section, it only has the bulk of its outer fibers on two sides so it is stronger in only one way in those same two directions. Relative to similar size tubing it will splay out the legs and fold under much lower loads, and it's not anywhere near as strong in twist.
The typical landscape trailer needs to have sides on it to keep those lawnmowers and leaf blowers from falling off, so because of this need they have an opportunity to build the ladder (or truss) style of side rails, and can get away with using the lighter and less expensive angle. The unity of the structure makes up for the angle's profile downfalls by really separating the outer fibers of the upper and lower rails, thus the combined moment of inertia of the double rail side frame is greatly increased over that of the single box tube design. The top rail helps keep the bottom rail from bending in its weak direction, and the bottom rail helps keep the top rail from bending in its weak direction.
By cutting off the top rail you are back to the weakness of a single small piece of angle.
However, the side walls on your cabin will make this all back up and then some, because, even tho they will be wood, they are very deep (tall) in section giving them an even greater moment of inertia, and more than making up for the difference between the strength of the wood fibers versus steel.
Take a piece of paper box (cracker box, chip board, index card, etc.), lay it flat on a table, hold the top down with one hand and pick the bottom up with the other. In this direction, the outer fibers between the front and back of the card are very close together so the card can not resist bending in this direction well at all.
Now do the same thing, card flat on the table, hold the top two corners down firmly with thumb and index, place the thumb and index of your other hand on the bottom two corners. While keeping the fingers of each hand the same distance apart from each other (don't pinch) try to bend the card around to either side so that your thumbs or index fingers come together (while keeping everything flat on the table). Can't do it without buckling the paper. Same paper, but now the fibers that you are trying to yield are the ones on the left and right sides of the card, and they are much farther apart. The fibers each have the same strength on a microscopic level, it is the geometry of the shape and the direction that the load is applied that makes the difference.
Your walls will stiffen and strengthen your trailer frame (not necessarily the other way around); and your bulkhead, front wall and cabinets will keep your walls from buckling in the flat direction (just like the flat surface did for the card trick).
This is why it is important to attach your cabin to the trailer well using several smaller fasteners along the length of the wall/floor, rather than using just a few larger fasteners only at the ends. Also, fit your wood joints well and use glue (in addition to screws) at assembly.
Hope that explains it well enough.
KC
My Build:
The Poet Creek Express Hybrid Foamie
Poet Creek Or Bust
Engineering the TLAR way - "That Looks About Right"
TnTTT ORIGINAL 200A LANTERN CLUB = "The 200A Gang"Green Lantern Corpsmen