OK, it's time to follow up on this post. I went ahead and bought a can of the Sharkhide protectant and used it on my tear as soon as I was done with the construction. So far, I have only good things to say about it. As long as you follow the instructions (thanks for the link MJ) it turns out really nice.
Basically you just saturate a cloth with the sharkhide (a cloth diaper works best), then wipe the finish on with long smooth strokes. It's best to do it when it's on the cooler side so it has more chance to flow out before the solvent evaporates. One can was enough to do 2 coats on my tear, and additional coats can be added at any time if you want additional protection. One coat is supposed to last years, so it's not something I should have to do often (maybe once a decade), especially since I keep it garaged.
The only (very minor) flaws in the finish were my own fault where I let the cloth get a little dry and you see a bit of streaking. But they're the kind of thing you stress about for an hour then never notice again!
I've towed the tear through the rain and mud, and no problems with staining of any kind. I just wash the tear like I would my car and it comes out spotless every time.
It's only been 6 months so far, but I'm very happy with the results. It's nice not to have to worry about my finish when I take it out.
