I had scorched my really nice stove up at Cave Creek cooking dinner. It really bugged me that I had done that. I pulled the top off the stove and took it in to the paint supplier the other day. They have a binder with just about every shade of paint you could think of in there. I matched up what I thought was a good one, had them mix it into a rattle can in single stage paint. I also had them put a splash of flattening agent into it so that the gloss would match.
I only painted the 2 sides visible on the box, all the rest top interior etc... is original color. Didn't clean the grease off the inside left flap however. I think it's a really good match so if you want to do touch up work that's a really good way to go in my opinion. Here's the before pic, bottom right stove.
Here's the after. I think someone would be hard pressed to really pick out much difference on it. Coleman had lots of various shades of green the flap is the original color. Doug