Wobbley wheels

Ask questions about Harbor Freight trailers, or questions about building your own...

Wobbley wheels

Postby suckerpunched » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:16 pm

So I finally get the energy to try and repack wheel bearings on my 1800# HF trailer, or at least check them. After jacking up trailer I find that both wheels are loose as if the bearing nut is not tightened. I checked them they were tight but were not compressing bearing all the way. The were still in good shape despite the traveling i'd done but this is just wrong. I tried using extra washers on the spindle but by the time the slack was taken up,,,the nut covered the cotter pin hole. It's like the spindles were not threaded far enough to allow proper adjustment... Could it be a bad axle,,,or bad hubs???? Anyone else run into this problem and what could be a fix that won't break the bank...I don't want it going down the road like a circus wagon.......and I never felt any shimmy or shake even at 65 mph.....
Any help would be gratefull.....TC
If you see my harley on a trailer,,,,call the police cause it's being stolen...
User avatar
suckerpunched
Teardrop Master
 
Posts: 295
Images: 22
Joined: Sun Sep 21, 2008 11:30 pm
Location: ogden Ut

Re: Wobbley wheels

Postby Kody » Tue Sep 10, 2013 8:23 am

This sounds extremely bad and quite serious. The last thing you need is for the wheels to come off at any stage. You stated that the nuts "were tight but were not compressing bearing all the way." The bearing/s should never be in a state of compression. I think you are saying that the bearing is not fully assembled together in the hub / axle?
I would start all over again and clean out the hub/s. Check that the back of the tapered bearing "rings" or raceways are seated on their respective shoulders in the hub. Seat the raceway down onto the seat using a hammer and an aluminium drift. I have a piece of aluminium about 3/4" x 1 1/2" x 6" that I
use for doing this.
The aluminium I use is a piece of the harder structural type. It is perfect for this job as it won't harm the bearing surfaces at all.
If the raceways are located fully against their seating shoulders, check out the two cones and see if they will sit down into the bearing the way it should.
Check the axle to see if the outer cone will slide firmly along the axle. The fit here needs to one where the bearing will slide without being thumped on with a hammer and drift. If this is too tight, the bearings will not work properly. They must be able to slide by pushing with your hand/fingers along the axle.
Leaving the seal off, assemble the hub and bearing onto the axle. Check if the outer cone (that's the smaller one) will slide onto the axle and into its bearing seating at the same depth it did, when placed into the raceway in the hub.
If this is seating correctly, measure the distance from the bearing to the castellated nut when the nut is screwed on so that a split pin can be pushed through the nut and axle. This distance will be the thickness of the required washer needed to complete the assembly.
Check that there is no step down from the axle where the bearing seats to the axle where the nut screws on. If there is a step (and sometimes there is) you will need a washer that fits over the step and is long enough to reach the back of the nut. Some people don't fit or include the correct size washer in the kit when you buy it. The result is that the washer is clamped against the shoulder and does not contact (or "compress") the bearing.
If there is a step on the axle, the first washer to be fitted, must seat on the face of the bearing and be long enough to extend past the shoulder by at least .040" When I assembled my new axle/bearings/hubs, I had to machine new washers as there was no way I could fit the original washer (spacers) so the split pin would go through the axle and have the required pressure on the bearings. The pressure was either so great that the bearing would not revolve or so loose that the wheel rattled. These are times when having a lathe is so great a blessing.
If you are unsure of the amount of pressure to have on the castellated nuts, a little too slack is better that a little to tight. When I assembled my hubs, I screwed the nut on with my fingers while rotating the wheel at the same time. When I could just feel the nuts were touching the washer/bearing and I could fit the split pin in the axle/nut, they were then perfect. The hubs were then filled with the appropriate amount of grease and reassembled for the last time. You will know for certain if you have the preload set correctly by taking the trailer around the block and checking the temperature of the hub/bearings. Slightly warm is good. If you cant hold your fingers on the hub, you have far too much preload on the bearings. Back the nut off and check for wobble and clearance of the washer. It can take an hour or two to get right or even just a few minutes, but it is so very important to get right.
Hope all this makes sense to you and helps you out.

Kody
Never be afraid to ask questions here, Prov. 11:14
User avatar
Kody
The 300 Club
 
Posts: 341
Images: 22
Joined: Fri Aug 24, 2012 5:14 am

Re: Wobbley wheels

Postby suckerpunched » Mon Sep 16, 2013 1:20 pm

Thanks for the info Kody but you have lost me.......My trailer came with two bearings, one washer one castle nut and one cotter pin. Bearings are the same size. The spindle has a small step that the inner bearing and seal go up against,,,,,not over,,,,,just up against. These are in the hub against the inner race. Then we have the outer race into which the outer bearing fits into. add the one washer, snug the nut till you feel resistance in wheel, loosen abit and install pin. Am I missing something somewhere???? The nut will just not go on far enuf to take out any play in the hub. If I install a washer or washers on against the step prior to installing hub it may take up the slack but that just doesn't seem right. I've got plenty of time to figure it out as I won't be using it this season. I wish I had a good IPB of the bearing assy to compare to....
Thanks again....TC
If you see my harley on a trailer,,,,call the police cause it's being stolen...
User avatar
suckerpunched
Teardrop Master
 
Posts: 295
Images: 22
Joined: Sun Sep 21, 2008 11:30 pm
Location: ogden Ut
Top

Re: Wobbley wheels

Postby Larry C » Mon Sep 16, 2013 4:28 pm

suckerpunched wrote:Thanks for the info Kody but you have lost me.......My trailer came with two bearings, one washer one castle nut and one cotter pin. Bearings are the same size. The spindle has a small step that the inner bearing and seal go up against,,,,,not over,,,,,just up against. These are in the hub against the inner race. Then we have the outer race into which the outer bearing fits into. add the one washer, snug the nut till you feel resistance in wheel, loosen abit and install pin. Am I missing something somewhere???? The nut will just not go on far enuf to take out any play in the hub. If I install a washer or washers on against the step prior to installing hub it may take up the slack but that just doesn't seem right. I've got plenty of time to figure it out as I won't be using it this season. I wish I had a good IPB of the bearing assy to compare to....
Thanks again....TC


I bought a HF trailer, not for TD build, but as a utility trailer. The inner races in the hubs WERE NOT seated to their stops in the hubs. This made adjustment impossible as tightening the nut would slightly push the inner race in further. Once I discover the problem, I seated the inner races with a socket that fit the hub. I was able to finally get proper adjustment. However, I have never pulled or even licensed the trailer.It sits in my garage collecting dust.
"If its worth doing it's worth doing Light"

http://www.tnttt.com/viewtopic.php?f=50&t=35852
Larry C
500 Club
 
Posts: 732
Images: 78
Joined: Sun Dec 27, 2009 9:37 am
Location: Finger Lakes
Top

Re: Wobbley wheels

Postby KCStudly » Mon Sep 16, 2013 6:21 pm

suckerpunched wrote:The spindle has a small step that the inner bearing and seal go up against,,,,,not over,,,,,just up against.


Usually the inner bearing seats up against the inner shoulder and the seal rides on the diameter of the shoulder. Are you saying that the inner seal is not traveling far enough to ride on the sealing surface of the spindle?

I don't think that is what you are saying because if that were the case then the nut should not be able to come anywhere close to seating on the spindle while the bearings are still loose.

Although others may find his input useful, your symptoms do not sound the same as Larry C's. His nuts kept getting loose because he was chasing the bearing race into the hub and it kept moving.

It sounds to me like one of the following:
1. Both of your hubs have been counter bored too deeply to suit the spindle shoulder dimension.
2. Both of your spindles were not turned enough to suit the bearing spread in your hubs.
3. The bearings are not thick enough (maybe a sourcing change by the OEM that got by the engineering dept... someone at the factory got a better deal on "the same but different")
4. The washer is incorrect.

Does the washer seat on the outer shoulder of the spindle with the nut, or is it just the nut that stops there and the washer can slide on with the bearing?

It is common for the washer on larger units to have an anti-rotation feature, such as an inner tab that rides in a slot in the threads. Does the HF spindle have this, and if so, can it be hanging up early?

I think what Kody was suggesting is that you may be able to correct for any of these possibilities by making (or having made) custom washers that allow the nut to apply pressure on the outer bearing inner race before the nut hits the shoulder on the spindle. If your washers are hanging on the spindles outer shoulder, it maybe as simple as increasing the ID of your existing washers, but I guess I would want to see it for myself before making that conclusion.

This cross section of a "generic" spindle/hub assembly might be of some use for talking purposes (scroll down a little).
KC
My Build: The Poet Creek Express Hybrid Foamie

Poet Creek Or Bust
Engineering the TLAR way - "That Looks About Right"
TnTTT ORIGINAL 200A LANTERN CLUB = "The 200A Gang"
Green Lantern Corpsmen
User avatar
KCStudly
Donating Member
 
Posts: 9640
Images: 8169
Joined: Mon Feb 06, 2012 10:18 pm
Location: Southeastern CT, USA
Top


Return to Trailer and Chassis Secrets

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests