absolutsnwbrdr wrote: I should have used oak.
I confess that I didn't go back and try to find where you made this joint, so I'm going on an assumption here. If that's a simple miter joint, as I suspect, you're going to need some better joinery. I suggest what is often referred to as a "saddle joint."
Quick sketch:

This will give you much greater glue area and therefore much greater strength. The two pieces should fit snugly. It'll take some careful table saw work, but that shouldn't be a big problem for a stepper like you.
I just love these after-the-fact suggestions. Don't you?
Here's hoping your fix holds!
