I have used many brands of coolers, Igloo, Coleman, Rubbermaid, some that claim to be Marine, some Extreme, all claim to hold ice longer than the other. But truly, the Colemans and so forth never hold ice more than a couple of days in really hot weather, and usually by the end of day one your stuff is already floating in water. (Although I have since overcome this particular problem. I now freeze gallon jugs of water and just put them in the cooler. After they melt we drink the water.)
I invested years ago in a Frigid Rigid for a boat we were living on. It honestly does hold ice for an entire week. But it is way too big for the galley of the teardrop so I had hoped like anything to find one of the cheaper coolers that would work well enough to be our sole cooler in the tear. I didn't really want to spend $300+ for a Yeti, since I already owned one expensive cooler. Well, after a number of trips and way too many daily trips to buy ice we just decided it wasn't worth it. We now haul the Frigid Rigid in the truck. It's heavy, and a pain to lift in and out, but it's worth it in the money we save in ice. And we have had this thing for over 15 years and it is still like new. Unless we drop it off a 10 story building I'm sure it will outlast us. We will likely never have to buy another cooler. You really do get what you pay for and if you spend the money up front for a cooler that will last a long time and hold ice a long time it will pay for itself eventually, plus save you a ton of aggravation and wasted or warm food and gas to run and get yet another bag of ice.
