The bathroom door does not hit the fridge cabinet in the first design. The real problem is one of "Feelings". It just feels too tight. It is only about 16" of clearance from the bathroom wall to the fridge cabinet. If it was 16" between two countertops it would feel OK. But 16" between a high wall and a countertop feels confining. And thank you for addressing my question. Much appreciated.
the question you need to answer is how long are you going to be in the area of the fridge and the bathroom wall if it is just to go in and out i would live with your first design
Mike