Thanks, all good suggestions. I did not know I should thin it with spirits. It seemed to go on thick, and still seemed a bit sticky several days later. How much sanding should I do? Just knock the shine off?
The varnish must be completely dry before you sand.
This time of year, depending on weather conditions and temperatures in a home workshop/garage, etc, it can take 4 days+ to be dry.
If you sand it too soon, it will gum up the paper and leave a bumpy mess.
If you are "just knocking the shine off" you are probably not sanding enough to remove any imperfections in the surface, which show themselves as "bumps".
The surface should feel very smooth, with the previous finish showing no "shine".
As with any varnish or paint, the finished product will only be as smooth as the prepared surface.
As in if the wood is rough and bumpy when the first coat of varnish is applied, it will likely be present in the final coat.
I must disagree with the poster that says it should be thinned to "make the biggest difference in getting the best finish".
It may work great for them, and for spraying, but thinning each coat is not recommended.
Thinning the first coat, or two, can be advantageous for getting better penetration into the wood.
Applied full strength, the final coats will/should turn out smooth and flat like a sheet of glass, with a great deal of depth.
Spar varnish is
very thick compared to polyurethane.
It can be very difficult to apply smoothly.
Temperature and weather conditions (humidity) can make it hard, or easy to apply.
Pre warming the wood, and varnish can be very helpful if you must work in a cool area.
As has been mentioned, stirring, not shaking is extremely important.
However, if you get carried away with stirring, you can still introduce a lot of bubbles into varnish.
If unsure, just look into the can after stirring, if there are a lot of bubbles, let it set for a while and try to be much more gentle on the second round.
Rob
Waiting for "someday" will leave you on your deathbed wondering why you didn't just rearrange your priorities and enjoy the time you had, instead of waiting for a "better" time to come along...