I used Miniwax Provincial Pine, because after testing 6 stains, I basically gave up. I don't LOVE this color, but it's by far the best I tested to bring out the grain. Of course, the luan tops and ply sides take it differently, but that's to be expected.
I haven’t tried that stain, because it isn’t in the Polyshades line, and I am trying to stay with Polyshades because it’s much easier to work with. I tried my samples for cabinets using both luan and my oak ply, and of course, they and the spruce frames all look different with the same stain. But, that gives it contrast which I do like.
The results are a fairly deep brown color. (Sorry, no pics yet. Remember that bad groin?) I now want to protect it with something that will give me the BRIGHTEST gloss possible. Is this epoxy, spar varnish or urethane? The edges will have thin, light strip molding to contrast. (I was considering using rope to match the rest of the TD, but I just don't know.)
I’ve always gotten a really good gloss just using the Minwax interior clear gloss polyeurothane, sometimes with two coats. The exterior Spar polyeurothane will add to the depth/darkness of the stain color as it has a yellowish appearance. I don’t know of an exterior polyeurothane that is perfectly clear, although there may be one somewhere. I’m using Clear Satin polyeurothane on my cabinets.