I think the diner back then was "Bay's Diner", or just "The Diner". That was the only one on Hwy. 1.
Becca,
I'm not sure of the name. That WAS a long time ago, you know. Anyway, the cafe wasn't on Hwy. 1. It was on Hwy 69, one block of Hwy 1, before crossing the tracks(the road to Pierre Part).
I travel through White Castle a few times a year, so I'm familiar with it.
John T.,
I'll be up your direction soon. DW and I are going to Pigeon Forge and Maggie Valley in May. How far are you from there?
va s'revoir,
Mike