by doug hodder » Sun May 06, 2012 11:32 pm
Whether or not one uses cloth on the exterior of a tear in my opinion depends on just how your walls are constructed. A 3/4" wall needs no cloth on it, nor does the top joint with the roof if done correctly. I've done 1/4" boat decks with no cloth on them, not a deck to be walked on though, but you're not walking on a tear roof either. Cloth on a thicker wall is a waste of time and money. The buzzword is "if done correctly". I have 1.5" roundovers on an all wood tear, no cloth or tape, 1/4" roof, no aluminum...just resin and it's held up fine for 6 years on one of my tears, on a boat deck...12 years, but you need to take care of it. I also use epoxy in the construction of the main tear body, however, I will pull all the screws on the side other than the main ones used on the crossmembers.
Resin on it's own works fine, but only if the structure construction is solid. It won't happen in 2 or 3 coats though. If you are counting on it to tighten up or correct any poor building techinques...then yeah, it won't do it....cloth or tape it. If you stuck it together with Liquid nails or Elmers and some drywall screws and top coated it with latex....then be prepared for problems down the road. My apologies to those of you that may have done this...no offense intended.
And while we're at it...check out the threads and see just how many people have had problems with the CPES. "What happened? I used 3 coats of CPES"? I've been here 8 years and have seen plenty of them. You drop a lot of coin on the materials...has none of the variable uses via additives as a regular epoxy...and it doesn't build up any thickness to speak of that can be sanded and flattened out for a nice paint job or depth for a clear finished woodie....You do 1 coat and that's it....it ain't gonna penetrate any more....it's done it's thing! Same thing with epoxy, once sealed....that's it. Epoxy will at least build up a thicker coats that can be worked with much less labor.
In the case of Rot Dr., It's called that because that's what it was originally intended for....rotten wood. That, however is just my assessment on it. Why else would they call it Rot Dr, because it was intended for new plywood? They just managed to find another use for it to expand their market and that's smart business. I know the guy is on this forum...but tough, I'd like him to explain why the word "ROT" is used if it weren't intended for that purpose.
Any of the other true epoxy systems can be used for a variety of applications, construction, fairing, top coating, casting. Just read up on it, they all have lots of different additives to make your system much more versatile than the CPE$....go to the manufacturers sites and get the straight dope. Under an aluminum skin, it's probably great as a sealer, but given the multitude of uses that an epoxy system has...I'll stick with it. I'm willing to bet that the premium custom boat builders aren't using CPES. I could be wrong however.
Just my rant...do whatcha' want, it's your trailer/ project. If you are looking for a quick fix easy way to do it, ..well, that probably isn't going to happen long term. There is no quick fix or short cut on a quality product...use the epoxy systems as they are designed and intended.....once you know how it all works and feel comfortable with it...then try to modify it how you want, but don't complain if it goes sideways when you messed with the formula. Rant over....other opinions will most certainly vary.